Saturday, May 19, 2012

The progression of William Naish's talent (1767-1800)

William Naish, one of three artist brothers, was lauded by his contemporaries after his early death for his talent. On the basis of much of this artist's work, this admiration may seem overly generous.  However, after a close study of his different styles, there appears to be more to this artist 'than meets the eye'!

A signed miniature by William Naish dated 1787. Painted when he was only 19 or 20 and a student at the Royal Academy, if it weren't for the distinctive signature, one could hardly equate the glumly staring portrait with the quality of the artist's work in the last few years of his life

Copyright V & A Museum London

Close up of signed portrait

Copyright V & A Museum London

A signed example a decade later showing the advance in his talent

A 'typical' male portrait from Naish's last decade
Copyright V & A Museum London

Close up showing his technique and also the 'giveaway' hallmarks of his work, discussed in detail in a previous article. Namely, the small 'dug out' circle in the corner of the eye, the chiselled delineation around the nostrils, the block of light from nose to upper lip and the circle of light on the chin

Copyright V & A Museum London

William Naish's almost unrecognisable best later work.  Instead of the enlarged eyes of the previous portrait, he uses a rather narrow eyed look and intense deep colours for the portrait and background.  When rare examples of Naish's best work appear at auction, they are usually heavily contested. Whether he deliberately  'pulled out the stops' to paint these superb miniatures when asked or paid to do so, or whether they were just a product of a 'good day',  is not known.  However, clearly something miraculous happened between his lumbering first attempts to paint a miniature and his last known works which stand up to comparison with other great artists of that era.  We find it sad that he died at such a young age, just when his talents were in full flower.  It could be conjectured that he was a depressive personality, judging from the haunted look of his self portrait, which was sold at Christies South Kensington about fifteen years ago. Unfortunately, we do not have a fine enough image to show it here.

A Curiosity

'Signed' miniature on ivory in Belle Epoque frame - a well made fake

Usually housed in 'piano key' frames, these 'decorative' miniatures are very common but are still collectible.

The 'signature' gives an air of authenticity

The overpainting over the printed base can easily be seen 

The back of the miniature showing the ivory striations 

The back of the frame - a bevelled mirror.
Such a lot of work went into this piece that it is a pity that it does not contain a properly painted miniature!
Offers anyone?!!